Възпроизведен дословно ...: Сингапур Съдът Навес от заповед от бивш панел, ръководен от CJI
The Singapore Supreme Court has set aside a ruling from an arbitration tribunal led by ex-Chief Justice of India Deepak Mishra after observing that 47 per cent of its contents - i.e., 212 of 451 paragraphs - were copied verbatim from two prior awards involving him.
Two other senior judges - ex-Madhya Pradesh High Court Justice Krishn Kumar Lahoti and ex-Jammu & Kashmir High Court Chief Justice Gita Mittal - were also part of that tribunal.
A Singapore Supreme Court bench of Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon and Justice Steven Chong found the earlier awards were used as " templates... to a very substantial degree " and observed, " It is undisputed that at least 212 paragraphs... were retained. This has several implications. "
The Supreme Court's Court of Appeal said that while it is not improper for an arbitrator to resolve two related disputes, the fault lay in " portions from the Parallel (i.e., the two earlier) Awards (being) reproduced in the (third) Award with...
Прочетете целия текст »
